Broadway shows have been a staple of entertainment for decades, drawing in large audiences with their dazzling performances and captivating storylines. While many shows have achieved great success and critical acclaim, there have been a few that have defied expectations and became huge hits, surpassing all predictions and becoming iconic in the world of theater. In this blog post, we will explore some of the Broadway shows that defied expectations and became massive hits, drawing in audiences from all over the world.
One of the most well-known examples of a Broadway show that defied expectations is the musical “The Phantom of the Opera”. Premiering in 1986, this Andrew Lloyd Webber production was met with mixed reviews from critics. However, audiences were immediately drawn to the captivating music and mesmerizing set design. Despite the initial skepticism, “The Phantom of the Opera” became the longest-running show in Broadway history, surpassing 13,000 performances and grossing over $6 billion worldwide. Its success has even led to productions in over 30 countries and multiple revivals on Broadway.
Another Broadway show that surpassed all expectations is “Wicked”. Based on the novel by Gregory Maguire, this musical tells the untold story of the witches of Oz. When it premiered in 2003, it was met with lukewarm reviews from critics. However, audiences were drawn to the captivating story, catchy music, and talented cast. “Wicked” quickly became a cultural phenomenon, grossing over $1 billion and becoming one of the top-selling musicals of all time. It has also won three Tony Awards and has spawned productions all over the world.
In 2015, “Hamilton” burst onto the Broadway scene and took the world by storm. Written by Lin-Manuel Miranda, this musical tells the story of American founding father Alexander Hamilton through a blend of hip-hop, R&B, and traditional show tunes. Despite its unconventional style and historical subject matter, “Hamilton” was an instant hit, receiving glowing reviews from critics and selling out performances for months in advance. It has won 11 Tony Awards and has grossed over $650 million on Broadway alone. Its success has also led to productions in Chicago, London, and an upcoming film adaptation.

Broadway Shows That Defied Expectations and Became Huge Hits
Many Broadway shows have also defied expectations by breaking boundaries and challenging traditional norms. One such show is “Rent”, a rock musical that premiered in 1996 and tackled issues such as AIDS, poverty, and LGBTQ+ rights. “Rent” received mixed reviews from critics, with some calling it groundbreaking and others criticizing its controversial subject matter. However, it quickly gained a cult following and became a massive hit, winning multiple Tony Awards and grossing over $280 million on Broadway. Its success also led to a film adaptation and multiple international productions.
Another groundbreaking show that defied expectations is “The Book of Mormon”. Written by the creators of the popular animated series “South Park”, this musical tells the story of two young Mormon missionaries sent to Uganda. With its irreverent humor and satirical take on religion, “The Book of Mormon” received backlash from some religious groups and was initially thought to be too controversial for Broadway. However, it became an instant success, winning nine Tony Awards and grossing over $500 million on Broadway alone. It has also spawned multiple productions worldwide and continues to draw in audiences with its clever and witty humor.
In addition to these Broadway shows, there have been many others that have defied expectations and became huge hits. “A Chorus Line”, a musical about the lives of Broadway dancers, was initially rejected by many theater producers but went on to win nine Tony Awards and become the longest-running musical on Broadway at the time. “Jersey Boys”, a jukebox musical about the rise of the band The Four Seasons, was also met with skepticism but became a beloved hit, winning four Tony Awards and grossing over $2 billion worldwide.
In conclusion, Broadway shows that defied expectations and became huge hits have proven that success in the world of theater cannot always be predicted. Whether it be through captivating music, groundbreaking storytelling, or challenging traditional norms, these shows have captured the hearts of audiences and solidified their place in Broadway history. As the saying goes, “the show must go on”, and these shows have certainly defied all expectations and gone on to become iconic and beloved by audiences worldwide.