“Just stay positive!” “Everything happens for a reason.” “Maybe this isn’t meant to be your path.” “At least you’re young.” If you’ve been through fertility treatment, you’ve almost certainly collected a set of well-meaning but deeply unhelpful phrases. They come from people who love you and don’t know what else to say. And they land like small cuts, each one a subtle message that your grief is something to be managed or corrected rather than honored.
What Toxic Positivity Actually Is
Toxic positivity is the cultural tendency to respond to suffering with cheerful reassurance, to invalidate difficult emotions in favor of an enforced optimism that prioritizes the comfort of the person saying it over the needs of the person experiencing pain. It’s not malicious — most people engaging in toxic positivity are trying to help, trying to say something that makes the situation feel better. But its effect is to communicate that negative emotions are unwelcome, that grief should be hurried through, and that struggling is a form of failure.
The difference between toxic positivity and genuine hope is important. Genuine hope acknowledges the difficulty of the present situation while maintaining the possibility of a better future. Toxic positivity bypasses the difficulty entirely, jumping straight to the resolution. “I know how hard this is, and I believe you have what it takes to keep going” is genuine hope. “I just know it’s going to work out!” is toxic positivity — it feels kind but costs nothing and offers nothing real.
The Harm Toxic Positivity Does
Research on emotional validation shows that having difficult feelings acknowledged — rather than redirected toward positivity — is more effective at reducing distress than reassurance. When someone responds to your grief with “just stay positive,” it doesn’t make the grief smaller; it adds shame to it. Now you’re not just sad; you’re sad in a way that is apparently unhelpful or wrong. That compounding is a real harm, even when it’s unintentionally inflicted.
Toxic positivity can also interfere with the grieving process itself. Grief moves through when it’s allowed to move through — when it’s acknowledged, expressed, and witnessed. When it’s consistently redirected toward optimism, it doesn’t disappear; it just goes underground, where it tends to express itself in less healthy ways — disconnection, depression, numbness, or explosive emotional release at inopportune moments.
How to Respond When You Encounter It
You don’t have to manage other people’s discomfort with your grief. A gentle but clear response to toxic positivity can protect both you and the relationship: “I know you’re trying to help, and what I actually need right now is just to be heard, not to be cheered up.” Most people, when invited to simply witness rather than fix, can actually do that — they just needed permission. Giving that permission is a form of advocating for your own needs, which is a deeply healthy thing to practice.
Cultivating Environments That Allow Real Emotion
One of the gifts of fertility community is that it tends to be a space where real emotion is permitted — where you don’t have to perform optimism and where people understand the complexity of hope and grief existing simultaneously. Identifying and cultivating relationships and spaces where honest emotion is welcome, and reducing your exposure to environments that consistently respond to your grief with toxic positivity, is one of the most important things you can do for your emotional health on this journey.
For a complete at-home insemination solution, the MakeAmom Babymaker Kit includes everything you need for a properly timed, sterile ICI cycle.
Further reading across our network: MakeAmom.com · Mosie.baby
This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare provider before making decisions about your fertility care.